首頁Home › 資訊設計與資料視覺化 Information Design & Data Viz
圖表誤導
1這是什麼What is it?
圖表誤導指圖表設計造成對資料的錯誤解讀,如截斷 Y 軸、不當雙軸、3D 效果扭曲、選擇性時間範圍。Darrell Huff 的《How to Lie with Statistics》(1954)是經典;Tufte 提出「謊言因子」(Lie Factor)量化圖形與資料變化比例的扭曲。
Misleading graphics are chart designs that cause misreading of data, such as truncated Y axes, improper dual axes, 3D distortion and selective time ranges. Darrell Huff's How to Lie with Statistics (1954) is a classic, and Tufte proposed the "Lie Factor" to quantify distortion between graphic and data change.
2常被用在哪種研究問題Typical research questions
常見問法:常見扭曲手法如何影響讀者判斷?
誤導性圖表可能影響判斷。本研究比較誤導與忠實版本,並以判讀正確率與信心評分,檢驗讀者是否能察覺。
Misleading charts can affect judgment. This study compares misleading and faithful versions and tests, through reading accuracy and confidence ratings, whether readers can detect them.
撰寫內容,非真實研究結果,請與指導教授討論後改寫。
Written as a model example, not a real finding. Please revise with your advisor.
3怎麼測它How to measure it
判讀實驗(含扭曲/無扭曲版本)
Measurement notes are written in Chinese. Switch to 中/EN to read them.
4代表文獻Key references
英文論文(2000 年後)English paper (post-2000)
Pandey, A. V., Rall, K., Satterthwaite, M. L., Nov, O., & Bertini, E. (2015). How deceptive are deceptive visualizations? An empirical analysis of common distortion techniques. CHI '15, ACM.
中文論文(2000 年後)
中文論文為預填檢索連結,請自行挑選一篇 2000 年後的期刊論文並核對作者、年份、出處後再引用。
英文引用來自模型整理,引用前請務必核對並閱讀原文。English citations are compiled by a model. Verify and read the original before citing.